The 1957 film Jailhouse Rock stands as a landmark in Elvis Presley’s career and rock ‘n’ roll cinema. This article delves into the movie’s critical reception, examining contemporary reviews and its lasting impact. We’ll explore its controversial themes, Elvis’s performance, and the film’s unique blend of humor and charm.
alt
Jailhouse Rock wasn’t just another Elvis movie; it was a cultural phenomenon. While audiences flocked to theaters, critics offered a mixed bag of opinions. Some lauded the film as a step forward for Elvis’s acting career, while others questioned its themes and Presley’s portrayal of a “bad boy” character. Variety, in its October 1957 review, acknowledged the film’s appeal to Presley’s fanbase, predicting its success particularly among “the cats.”
Jailhouse Rock Film: Elvis Takes Center Stage
Unlike his previous two films, Jailhouse Rock placed Elvis squarely in the spotlight. He dominated screen time, a bold move that placed the film’s success entirely on his shoulders. This prominence allowed critics to closely scrutinize his performance. The New York Times was particularly harsh, criticizing Elvis’s diction and “sheepish” acting.
alt
However, other critics recognized Elvis’s growth as an actor. Variety conceded that while not a “great shakes,” Elvis “gets by well enough.” Hortense Morton of the San Francisco Examiner went further, predicting Elvis would eventually “turn into quite an actor.” Even Elvis’s singing was scrutinized, with the New York Times noting his improved diction while also mocking his signature dance moves. Notably, Elvis had to adjust his singing style to portray his character’s evolution from a novice to a seasoned performer.
Jailhouse Rock Film: Controversy and Cultural Impact
In 1957, rock ‘n’ roll was still a rebellious force, and Jailhouse Rock‘s themes of crime and rebellion sparked controversy. The Los Angeles Times criticized the film’s association of rock ‘n’ roll with “crime, greed, profanity, vulgarity, and brutality.” They questioned the wisdom of portraying Elvis, a teen idol, in such a negative light. Concerns were raised about the film’s potential to incite teenage riots, a fear that ultimately proved unfounded.
Jailhouse Rock Film: Enduring Humor and Charm
Beyond the controversy, Jailhouse Rock possesses a unique charm and humor that contributes to its enduring appeal. The outlandish premise of a convict becoming a music sensation lends itself to comedic moments. Memorable scenes, like Vince Everett’s forced kiss and the horsemeat commercial set to “Treat Me Nice,” are both humorous and iconic.
alt
Jailhouse Rock remains a significant film in Elvis Presley’s legacy. It showcased his evolving talent as a performer and solidified his status as a cultural icon. While controversial in its time, the film’s humor, music, and Elvis’s captivating presence continue to resonate with audiences today. It serves as a testament to the power of rock ‘n’ roll and the enduring charisma of Elvis Presley.
