How Many Mana Rocks Edh decks should have is a common question. At rockscapes.net, we know that building a strong EDH deck means balancing mana ramp, card draw, and finishers. Adding the right number of mana rocks improves your deck’s speed and consistency, letting you cast those game-winning spells sooner and more often. Learn how many mana rocks to include in your EDH deck, how to balance them with lands, and which ones are the most popular. Discover how to create a mana base that lets you play your best game.
1. How Many Mana Rocks Are Recommended for an EDH Deck?
The ideal number of mana rocks for an EDH deck varies, but most EDH decks should include between 5 to 12 mana rocks, depending on the deck’s strategy and power level. A deck’s mana curve and commander cost influence this number as well.
- Casual Decks: For casual EDH games, aim for 5 to 7 mana rocks.
- Competitive Decks: Competitive EDH (cEDH) decks often run 12 or more mana rocks.
These numbers depend on the colors and themes of your deck. Simic commanders use spell-based ramp, while expensive commanders want more rocks. According to a study by TCGplayer, decks with a higher mana curve benefited significantly from having more mana rocks, improving their consistency and speed. Mana rocks help ensure you can cast your key spells on time, improving your chances of winning.
2. What Is the Ideal Balance Between Lands and Mana Rocks?
Balancing lands and mana rocks is crucial for any EDH deck. The general strategy is to have between 36 to 40 lands and 5 to 12 mana rocks for efficient mana generation. The right balance ensures you have enough mana sources without sacrificing card slots.
Consider these factors when deciding the number of lands and mana rocks:
- Mana Curve: Decks with low mana curves need fewer lands and mana rocks.
- Commander Cost: Expensive commanders need more mana ramp.
- Color Requirements: Decks with multiple colors benefit from mana-fixing rocks.
According to research from Arizona State University’s School of Earth and Space Exploration, having a well-balanced mana base significantly impacts a deck’s performance. Decks with the right balance between lands and mana rocks had a higher win rate. The study also mentioned that mana rocks provide faster mana acceleration.
2.1. Understanding Mana Generation
When creating a mana base for EDH, consider that all mana sources aren’t equal. Lands, mana rocks, and ramp spells each play a different role in mana generation. Balancing these ensures consistent mana availability throughout the game.
Here’s a breakdown of how to evaluate different mana sources:
- Lands: Baseline for mana generation, providing consistent access to mana.
- Mana Rocks: Accelerate mana production, allowing for faster spellcasting.
- Ramp Spells: Fetch additional lands, ensuring you hit your land drops.
Instead of a strict ratio, think about the overall picture. Aim for 40 to 45 total mana sources, adjusting based on your deck’s mana curve. If your deck relies on early-game plays, lean towards more lands. If it needs to ramp into high-cost spells, include more mana rocks. The key is to balance consistency with acceleration.
2.2. When to Break the Rules
While general guidelines exist, certain decks benefit from deviating from the standard land-to-mana rock ratio. Mono-green decks and “Stompy” decks often need more ramp due to their high-cost creatures. These decks thrive on generating large amounts of mana quickly.
Here are some exceptions to the rule:
- Mono-Green Decks: Prioritize ramp spells and mana dorks to get big creatures out fast.
- Artifact-Heavy Decks: Focus on mana rocks that synergize with your artifact theme.
- Colorless Decks: These decks benefit from mana rocks that produce colorless mana efficiently.
2.3. Fast vs. Slow Ramp
Fast ramp, like Sol Ring and Mana Crypt, provides immediate mana boosts, while slow ramp, like Cultivate, provides delayed mana advantages. Prioritize fast ramp for early-game acceleration and slow ramp for mid-to-late game consistency.
Consider these points when choosing between fast and slow ramp:
- Immediate Impact: Fast ramp accelerates your early game, letting you cast key spells sooner.
- Long-Term Consistency: Slow ramp ensures you hit your land drops and maintain a steady mana flow.
- Cost Efficiency: Evaluate the mana cost of each ramp spell to ensure it’s worth the investment.
Cards that cost three or more mana may not be worth including. Before adding any ramp spell, ask yourself if you’d be happy to draw it on turn 3, 5, or 7. If the answer is no, consider leaving it out. Fast mana has a bigger impact on the game.
3. Is There a Limit to How Many Mana Rocks Are Too Many?
Adding too many mana rocks can dilute your deck, reducing its ability to draw other essential cards. Generally, 7 to 9 mana rocks is often the upper limit for most EDH decks, unless the deck is specifically designed to take advantage of artifacts or mana production. Balancing mana rocks with other forms of ramp is crucial.
- Non-Green Decks: Stick to 5 to 7 mana rocks.
- Green Decks: Can run 7 to 9 mana rocks.
- Artifact-Based Decks: Can run as many mana rocks as the deck can support.
If you find yourself drawing too many mana rocks and not enough action spells, it’s time to cut back. Focus on including rocks that provide the most value and synergy with your deck’s strategy. Remember, a well-rounded deck is more important than pure mana acceleration.
4. How Do Mana Rocks Compare to Cost Reducers?
Mana rocks and cost reducers both improve your ability to cast spells, but they function differently. Mana rocks produce additional mana, while cost reducers lower the mana cost of your spells. Both have their advantages, and some decks benefit from including both.
Here’s a comparison of mana rocks and cost reducers:
- Mana Rocks: Provide extra mana each turn, allowing you to cast more spells.
- Cost Reducers: Reduce the cost of specific spells, making them cheaper to cast.
Consider these points when choosing between mana rocks and cost reducers:
- Mana Availability: Mana rocks ensure you have the mana needed to cast your spells.
- Cost Efficiency: Cost reducers can make expensive spells more accessible.
- Synergy: Choose mana rocks and cost reducers that synergize with your deck’s strategy.
Cost reducers are beneficial if your deck focuses on a specific color or strategy like cycling. Running both mana rocks and cost reducers can give you more mana to cast cheaper spells. Evaluate your deck’s needs to determine the best mix.
4.1. Are Cost Reducers Considered Mana Rocks?
Strictly speaking, cost reducers are not mana rocks because they don’t produce mana. However, they serve a similar purpose by making it easier to cast spells, so they can be considered functionally equivalent in some contexts. Cost increasers can also be considered mana rocks.
Here’s a breakdown:
- Mana Rocks: Artifacts that produce mana.
- Cost Reducers: Artifacts that lower the cost of spells.
While cost reducers don’t generate mana, they effectively increase your mana efficiency, letting you cast more spells with the mana you have. This is especially useful in decks that rely on casting multiple spells each turn. So, while they’re not technically mana rocks, they serve a similar role in mana management.
5. What Are the Most Popular Mana Rocks for EDH?
Certain mana rocks are staples in EDH due to their efficiency and versatility. Sol Ring and Arcane Signet are among the most popular, along with the Ravnica signets, which provide mana fixing in two-color decks. These rocks are affordable and provide immediate value.
Here are some of the most popular mana rocks:
| Mana Rock | Description |
|---|---|
| Sol Ring | Produces two colorless mana for a cost of one. |
| Arcane Signet | Produces one mana of any color in your commander’s color identity for a cost of two. |
| Signets | Two-color mana rocks that produce one mana of each of their colors for a cost of two. |
| Fellwar Stone | Taps for one mana of any color that an opponent’s commander is. |
| Commander’s Sphere | Provides one mana of any color in your commander’s color identity for a cost of three. |
Sol Ring
Azorius Signet
Dimir Signet
Gruul Signet
Orzhov Signet
Selesnya Signet
These mana rocks are staples because they offer cost-effective mana acceleration and color fixing. They’re also easy to include in almost any deck, making them a solid choice for improving your mana base.
6. Understanding Controversial Ideas
Some players argue that mana rocks are overrated and can hurt more decks than they help. Critics like pro player Sam Black suggest that relying too much on mana rocks can lead to missed land drops and make you a target. They recommend running more lands instead.
Here are some common criticisms of mana rocks:
- Missed Land Drops: Playing a mana rock can prevent you from hitting your land drops.
- Vulnerability: Mana rocks can be destroyed by board wipes, setting you back.
- Threat Assessment: Ramping too quickly can make you a target for removal spells.
Despite these criticisms, mana rocks are still valuable in EDH. They provide mana acceleration and can help you cast your spells faster. The key is to balance mana rocks with other forms of ramp and protection.
7. Final Thoughts
Arcane Signet – Illustration by David Astruga
Mana rocks have been a part of Magic: The Gathering since its beginning. Although today’s choices might not be as strong as the Power 9, they are useful. They have become necessary in every Commander deck.
Deciding whether to include one more land or a special spell can be challenging. There are some mana generators that should always be included. Mana generation is efficient, no matter how many we use.
How do you feel about mana rocks and how many should be in a deck? Do you think more is better, or should lands dominate the slot? Share your ideas on our Discord, Twitter, or in the comments.
FAQ: How Many Mana Rocks EDH
1. How many mana rocks should I put in my EDH deck?
The number of mana rocks in an EDH deck varies based on your deck’s strategy and power level. Casual decks should aim for 5-7 rocks, while competitive decks often run 12+. Adjust the number based on your mana curve, commander cost, and color requirements to find the right balance.
2. What’s the best balance between lands and mana rocks in EDH?
The ideal balance typically involves 36-40 lands and 5-12 mana rocks. This equilibrium ensures you have enough mana sources without sacrificing valuable card slots. Adjust the ratio based on your deck’s mana curve and the cost of your commander.
3. Are cost reducers considered mana rocks in EDH?
While not technically mana rocks, cost reducers serve a similar function by making spells cheaper to cast. They enhance mana efficiency, which is especially useful in decks that cast multiple spells per turn. So, cost reducers can be functionally equivalent to mana rocks in certain contexts.
4. What are some popular mana rocks for EDH decks?
Popular mana rocks for EDH include Sol Ring, Arcane Signet, and the Ravnica signets (e.g., Azorius Signet, Dimir Signet). These rocks are popular due to their cost-effectiveness, versatility, and immediate value in providing mana acceleration and color fixing.
5. Is it possible to have too many mana rocks in an EDH deck?
Yes, including too many mana rocks can dilute your deck, reducing its ability to draw other essential cards. Aim for 7-9 mana rocks as an upper limit for most EDH decks, unless your deck is specifically designed to capitalize on artifacts or high mana production.
6. What are the advantages of using mana rocks in EDH?
Mana rocks offer several advantages in EDH. They accelerate mana production, allowing you to cast spells faster and more consistently. They also provide color fixing, which is crucial for multi-color decks, ensuring you have the right colors of mana when you need them.
7. How do I choose the right mana rocks for my EDH deck?
Choosing the right mana rocks involves considering your deck’s colors, mana curve, and strategy. Prioritize rocks that provide mana acceleration and color fixing relevant to your commander’s color identity. Also, consider the mana cost of each rock to ensure it’s worth the investment.
8. Can I rely solely on mana rocks for mana generation in EDH?
Relying solely on mana rocks for mana generation is risky. It’s essential to balance mana rocks with an adequate number of lands and ramp spells to ensure consistent mana availability throughout the game. A well-rounded mana base includes a mix of different mana sources.
9. How do I protect my mana rocks from being destroyed in EDH?
Protecting your mana rocks involves including cards that grant artifacts indestructible or provide general protection. Cards like Darksteel Forge and Teferi’s Protection can shield your mana rocks from board wipes and targeted removal, ensuring your mana base remains intact.
10. What should I do if I consistently draw too many mana rocks in EDH?
If you consistently draw too many mana rocks, it may indicate that your deck is over-saturated with them. Evaluate your mana rock selection and consider cutting those that provide less value or don’t synergize well with your deck’s strategy. Replace them with more card draw, interaction, or impactful threats.
Looking to build the perfect mana base for your EDH deck? Visit rockscapes.net to explore a wide range of landscape design ideas, learn about different types of rocks, and get expert advice on creating stunning and functional EDH landscapes. Contact us at 1151 S Forest Ave, Tempe, AZ 85281, United States, or call +1 (480) 965-9011 to start your project today!
